Shane Bouel
2 min readApr 15, 2024

--

Thank you for sharing your perspective on the adoption conversation in the context of abortion rights and motherhood. As an adoptee who advocates for the abolition of adoption, I resonate with some of the points you raised while also offering a different lens on this complex issue.

Firstly, I appreciate your acknowledgment of the complexities surrounding adoption and the recognition that it's not a simple solution or consolation prize. Adoptees often grapple with identity struggles and the profound impacts of adoption throughout their lives, and it's crucial to elevate these voices in discussions like these.

However, I want to highlight a critical aspect that I believe requires deeper consideration. The link between abortion bans and increased adoption rates is indeed problematic. When abortion options are limited or restricted, it can lead to a rise in adoptions, which can perpetuate a cycle of systemic issues and ethical dilemmas.

Forced birthing or coerced adoption should never be seen as a viable alternative to protecting reproductive rights. It's essential to prioritize the autonomy and agency of pregnant individuals, especially young mothers facing overwhelming circumstances. The focus should be on providing comprehensive support, resources, and options that empower individuals to make informed choices about their bodies and futures.

Furthermore, the narrative surrounding adoption needs to evolve beyond fairy tales and oversimplified solutions. Adoptees often navigate complex emotions, including loss, identity struggles, and the impact of societal perceptions. By amplifying adoptee voices and acknowledging the nuanced realities of adoption, we can foster more meaningful dialogue and advocate for systemic reforms that prioritize the well-being of all involved parties.

I applaud your commitment to raising awareness and engaging in dialogue on these important topics. It's through conversations like these that we can challenge harmful narratives, advocate for social change, and strive for a more just and equitable world for all.

Thank you for your thoughtful contributions to this ongoing conversation.

--

--

Shane Bouel
Shane Bouel

Written by Shane Bouel

Using creativity to lift standards of ethics & morality by questioning half-truths and denouncing the conservancy of inhumane ideologies.

No responses yet